Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Symmetries and Judgment under Political Pressure: Keynes, Freud, and the Structure of Economic Uncertainty

Ceschi Maria Vittoria, Scuola di Psicanalisi Freudiana

This paper proposes the physics of symmetry as a structural vocabulary, mobilized as a bridge-concept across distinct epistemic domains. The principal contribution is a tripartite mapping: the three forms of Keynesian uncertainty (as systemized by Carabelli) — ignorance, low weight of argument, and incommensurability — correspond to three structurally distinct configurations of unstable symmetry, broken respectively by convention, by practical reasonableness, and by the operation of the Freudian drive. In each configuration, judgment is the faculty that performs the breaking, and the mode in which it operates depends on which configuration of uncertainty obtains. The reading offers a structural alternative to standard decision-theoretic treatments of uncertainty, which represent it as a single deficit of information to be compensated for by probability weights. Here, by contrast, uncertainty is a configuration whose internal structure determines what mode of judgment is structurally appropriate to break it — a typological rather than continuous treatment of the object decision theory studies. The framework extends to the conference's governing question by treating sustained political pressures as external fields that stabilize specific theoretical configurations as apparently natural — distinguishing kinds of pressure that can be critiqued from within economic theory from those that operate at the level of what economic theory is.

Area:

Keywords: Keynes, decision theory, uncertainty, symmetry, judgement, convention, weight of argument, incommensurability, political pressure, history of economic thought

Please Login in order to download this file