Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

From Ricardo to Hodgskin: Competing Interpretations of Market and Natural Prices

SINGH AVANTIKA, Azim Premji University

This paper compares how David Ricardo and the ‘Ricardian Socialist’ Thomas Hodgskin understood the ideas of market price and natural price, two central concepts in classical political economy. Although Hodgskin was strongly influenced by Ricardo, he reached different conclusions about prices, especially how prices are formed and what they reveal about capitalist society. By placing their argument side by side, the paper shows that their disagreement is not only theoretical but also reflects deeper differences in method and social vision. The paper first outlines Ricardo’s account of market and natural prices as developed in Principles of Political Economy and Taxation (1817). For Ricardo, the natural price of a commodity depends on its cost of production, especially the amount of labor required, including labor embodied in capital. Market prices may temporarily diverge from natural prices due to changes in supply and demand, but competition tends to bring them back to their natural level. This distinction allows Ricardo to analyze long-run price relations and the distribution of income between wages, profits and rent. In Ricardo’s framework, profits arise naturally from the use of capital and are treated as a normal part of the economic system. The paper then turns to Hodgskin’s views on natural prices and social prices drawing mainly from his book Labor Defended Against the claims of Capital and popular Political Economy (1825). Hodgskin accepts the idea that labor is the source of value, but he rejects Ricardo’s understanding of natural price. For Hodgskin, natural price does not describe prices under capitalism as it actually exists. Instead, it refers to the price that would prevail in a society where labourers received the full product of their work. He argues that profits are not a natural reward for capital, but a result of political arrangements that allow capitalists to appropriate part of labor’s output. As a result, the gap between natural price and social price is not temporary or accidental, but a permanent feature of capitalist society. By comparing these two views, the paper argues that Hodgskin both builds on and challenges Ricardo’s value theory. While Ricardo uses the concept of natural price to explain equilibrium and distribution, Hodgskin uses it as a critical tool to expose exploitation and institutional privilege.

Area:

Keywords: Ricardain Socialist, natural price, social price, Thomas Hodgskin, Ricardo

Please Login in order to download this file