Is Neoclassical Economics Responsible for Neoliberalism? Inequality, Climate Catastrophe, and the Crisis of Democracy
1. Problem The critics of neoliberalism argue that neoclassical economics with its theories supports neoliberalism. In this narration, economic thinking leads to crucial social problems: 1. Rising inequalities: market supports social Darwinism, 2. Falling democracy and rising authoritarianism: consumer society leads to hyperindividualism and erosion of the common good, 3. Climate crisis: fetishization of GDP and growth. The crucial problem with this argument is that the connection between neoliberalism and neoclassical economics is made implicitly. The critics do not explicitly demonstrate how neoclassical economics paradigm leads to problems associated with neoliberalism. 2. Paper’s goal The paper aims to analyze if neoclassical economics prepares the ground for neoliberalism and leads to problems: 1. Rising inequality, 2. Falling democracy, 3. Climate crisis. The comparison between neoliberalism and neoclassical economics is very problematic because both are amorphous paradigms with various interpretations. To make a comparison, I employ a Lakatosian rational reconstruction. I define neoclassical economics and neoliberalism by their hard cores, protective belts, and heuristics. 3. Structure In 1 section, I reconstruct neoliberalism as a Lakatosian scientific research programme. I analyze various stands in neoliberalism (1. Austrians and Hayek, 2. Ordoliberals, 3. Chicago School, 4. Public Choice). Firstly, I identify three hard cores of neoliberalism: 1. Methodological individualism: subjectivism; being against collectivism and social values, 2. Competitive market: efficient system based on spontaneous order, 3. Value-freeness: neither assessing individuals’ preferences nor competitive market. Secondly, I analyze neoliberalism’s protective belt. I analyze how hard cores are protected from criticism and why neoliberalism survives to this day despite criticism. Thirdly, I analyze neoliberalism’s heuristics: ways in which scientists work within the paradigm. I show how the logic of market is extended to every sphere of life by focusing on Becker’s economic imperialism. In 2 section, I reconstruct neoclassical economics as a scientific research programme. I identify the same hard cores as in neoliberalism: 1. Methodological individualism, 2. Competitive market, 3. Value-freeness. I demonstrate how they relate to various economic theories. Next, I analyze the protective belt to show how neoclassical economics could incorporate the criticism without changing the hard cores. I focus on behavioral economics, new institutional economics, and new neoclassical synthesis to show the unchaining nature of neoclassical economics. Lastly, I analyze the heuristics. I analyze how neoclassical economists' view of reality is shaped by the hard cores. In 3 section, I compare neoliberalism and neoclassical economics in the context of social problems. I analyze how each hard core: 1. Methodological individualism, 2. Competitive market, 3. Value-freeness relates to problems: 1. Rising inequalities, 2. Falling democracy and rising authoritarianism, 3. Climate crisis. Moreover, I demonstrate how hard cores influence reality by analyzing protective belts and heuristics. The analysis is done for neoliberalism and neoclassical economics respectively. 4. Conclusions My analysis reveals the similarities between neoliberalism and neoclassical economics at the methodological level. I argue that neoclassical economics prepares the ground for neoliberalism and can lead to social problems: 1. Rising inequalities, 2. Falling democracy and rising authoritarianism, 3. Climate crisis. However, my conclusion is limited. I do not claim causality between neoclassical economics’ theories and specific neoliberal policies. Moreover, I do not blame economics for current social problems. Instead, I argue that neoclassical economics prepares the ground for neoliberalism as they share the same hard cores.
Area:
Keywords: neoliberalism; neoclassical economics; Lakatos; philosophy of science