Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

William James: Classical Liberal or New Liberal?

Rizzo Mario, New York University

It is well understood that William James did not have an explicit and well-developed political philosophy. And yet he is most often considered a "liberal." This is perhaps in part due to his association with John Dewey. But Dewey's brand of liberalism did not emerge until after James's death in 1910. Another possibility is that he is considered a liberal because of his explicit anti-paternalist stances on American policy toward the Philippines and on the subject of medical licensure. More fundamentally, I will argue, it rests on his conception of the individual and the myriad ways people find meaning. But this leaves open just what kind of liberal he is -- a classical liberal or a "new liberal" in the 20th century sense promoted by John Dewey? I will argue that he is an incomplete liberal because he had no way of achieving his ideal that as many plans (demands)of individuals as possible should be satisfied. In this regard I explore the options or paths he could have taken. Some take him in the direction of a twentieth century version of classical liberalism and others take him in the direction of Dewey.

Area:

Keywords: individual meaning, paternalism, liberalism, Dewey