Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Between Conservatism and Neoliberalism: Erik von Kuehnelt Leddihn, Opus Dei, and Catholic Neoliberalism in Latin America

Castillo Garcia Cesar, Wesleyan University

One of the most compelling dimensions of neoliberalism is its relationship to Catholicism. During the Cold War, conservative Catholics reinterpreted Catholic social teaching in defense of capitalism. This reinterpretation centered on two principles: individual effort as the foundation of social mobility (work ethic) and staunch anti-Marxism. The latter can be identified in the ideas of the Austrian intellectual Erik von Kuehnelt-Leddihn—a close associate of the German ordoliberal Wilhelm Röpke and a contributor to the journal Ordo—and highlights its similarities with the principles that informed Opus Dei’s initiatives in Peru. Kuehnelt-Leddihn became a prominent figure in U.S. conservatism, collaborating with Russell Kirk on editorial projects and emerging as an intellectual authority among right-wing Catholics, including early American Opus Dei groups. He explained differences in national development through the concept of Arbeitsbereitschaft (readiness to work), which he employed in conveying Latin American elites’ interpretations of underdevelopment to U.S. conservative circles. In doing so, Kuehnelt-Leddihn reproduced a patronizing conception of Catholic charity culturally shaped by Hispanismo, attributing indigenous poverty to laziness rather than to structural conditions. His notion of Arbeitsbereitschaft stood in direct opposition to the structural transformation advocated by Liberation Theology, a movement rooted in Latin America and intellectually consolidated in Peru. Institutionally, Arbeitsbereitschaft aligned with Opus Dei’s conception of work as a personal path to holiness, which informed its developmentalist initiatives in Latin America, as reflected in Nuestro Tiempo, the main journal of Opus Dei’s Universidad de Navarra (Spain). In Peru, these principles were institutionalized through the technical schools run by the Territorial Prelature of Yauyos (Condoray and ERPA/Valle Grande) and through Opus Dei’s Universidad de Piura, all of which sought to preserve existing social hierarchies while framing inequality as an individual rather than a structural issue.

Area:

Keywords: neoliberalism, conservatism, Opus Dei, Erik Kuehnelt-Leddihn, work ethic

Please Login in order to download this file