Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Ragnar Frisch's Proposal for an International Clearing Agency: Origins, Alterations, and Fate

Rivot Sylvie, University of Haute-Alsace
Dupont-Kieffer Ariane, PHARE, University Paris 1

In July 1962, Joan Robinson and Ragnar Frisch were invited to the Britain-Commonwealth-EFTA conference in London. On 18 July, Robinson gave a speech in response to Frisch’s address the previous day on 'A tentative draft of a multilateral trade clearing agency'. Frisch’s proposal for an international clearing agency to promote “world economic development and social progress” was similar to his earlier idea for a multilateral agency as set out in Circulation Planning (1934). Compared to the latter, the former is much shorter. Its core is the identification of nine principles for establishing international trade. While some of the 1934 guidelines are still relevant, Frisch appears to abandon Walrasian general equilibrium in favour of a Keynesian circuit approach. While not abandoning his market approach, Frisch develops an analysis in terms of trade disequilibria and the impact of a negative balance of payments on economic growth. This paper will investigate the evolution of the concept of a clearing agency between the 1930s and the late 1960s, and identify the reasons behind this evolution. We assume that this evolution is due to a combination of factors: 1) the application of Frisch's understanding of market coordination failures to explain shortages and bottlenecks in international trade; and 2) Frisch's dialogue with Keynesian economists (e.g. Joan Robinson) at United Nations commissions after 1946, EFTA after 1955, and the OECD (formerly the OEEC), where the Keynesian approach to international trade was extensively discussed.

Area:

Keywords: international trade, stabilisation, planification

Please Login in order to download this file