Soviet historians of economic thought under the ideological pressure
Soviet history of economic thought was always under the heavy ideological pressure. Its official title was the critique of bourgeois political economy. The terms “vulgar” and “apologetic” were also very important. The term “critique” instead of neutral “history” was used to underline the negative attitude towards the object in question. The term “bourgeois” denoted the influence of respective class interests on economic theory in question. As long as the bourgeoisie struggled against the feudal order the bourgeois political economy was progressive and scientific (trying to discover the essence of economic phenomena). But as soon as the bourgeoisie gained the political power, and the essence of capitalist economy was discovered by Karl Marx the situation changed radically. The scientific political economy gave way to the vulgar one which did not transcend the horizon of common sense. It also became apologetic that is defending the status-quo. Therefore, the critico-historical analysis of economic science after Marx’s historical discoveries had to disclose its vulgar and apologetic character and use citations from Marx’s and Lenin’s works as main arguments. Especially awkward was the use of label “vulgar” in the case of marginalist theory not deducible to worldview of economic agents. Besides, the description of the “criticized’ statements was considered not necessary and even dangerous. Principal condemnations used against the historians of economic thought was “objectivism” - the lack of communist critique of bourgeois theories and “cosmopolitism” (which was added to objectivism after the World war II) which meant high estimation of Western works which were presumable inferior to Russian ones. The majority of Soviet historians followed the prescribed line and do not interest us here. In our focus will be four serious researchers which tried to describe and analyze the development of economic thought avoiding the narrow prescribed limits. We will deal with four outstanding historians and their relationships with ruling ideology. Our presentation will consist of four parts: Israel Blyumin and the allegation of “objectivism” Viktor Shteyn and the allegation of “cosmopolitism” Andrey Anikin who placed in his books living personalities instead of dry ideological schemes Revold Entov who fulfilled the enlightenment function when it became possible (mainly writing forewords to Western authors). Noteworthy, three out of the four our heroes worked in the Institute of World Economy and International relations of the Academy of Sciences. The main task of this Institute was to inform the Soviet rulers about the true situation in Western economies The scholars working in this Institute (Blyumin spent there the last years of his life but Anikin and Entov spent there most fruitful years) were to a certain extent (this extent needs special consideration) not exposed to the ideological press. That is why an idea of dual functions of bourgeois political economy(apologetic and practical) was suggested by Abram Mileykovsky in this Institute and the series “Contemporary Western economic thought” emerged there too.
Area:
Keywords: Soviet history of economic thought, Marxist ideology
Please Login in order to download this file