The 1990s minimum wage wars in the U.S.A. and the U.K. or how less theory made labor economics more political
In 1989, the Fair Labor Standards Act is amended to increase the federal minimum wage in the U.S.A. from $3.35 to $3.80 per hour in April 1990 and $4.25 a year later. This came after about a decade during which the minimum wage was frozen (under Reagan) and a relatively large theoretical and empirical consensus was established in economics about its negative relation with employment. On November 15, 1991, Cornell University hosted a conference entitled “New Minimum Wage Research”. There, economists presented empirical studies motivated by the 1989 amendment to an audience constituted of their peers, representatives of liberal and conservative think-thanks as well as policy makers. From this date and at least until the early 2000s, the New Minimum Wage Research developed in the U.S.A. through raging controversies, notably over Myth and Measurement (Card and Krueger, 1995). Indeed, as Thomas Leonard (2000: 117) – the sole historian of economics to have studied the topic – noted: this work generated significant "sound and fury" within labor economics, the broader field of economics, and even in public discourse. In the U.K., the 1993 Trade Union Reform and Employment Rights Act abolishes the sectorial regulation of minimum wage (i.e., the wages councils). A small group of economists took this opportunity to conduct empirical studies in the spirit of natural experiments on the relation between minimum wage and employment (Dickens et al., 1993; Machin and Manning, 1994). While their results echoed the ones in the U.S.A. about the absence of a negative relation, they generated much less controversies in the U.K. Our goal in this paper is to provide a comparative history of the birth of the New Minimum Wage Research in the U.S.A. and in the U.K. We focus (i) on the connections between these two countries and (ii) on the relations between the academia, the press and politics (both within and across these two countries). We are notably interested in how the method of natural experiments “that would provide convincing evidence even to a skeptic” (Card and Krueger, 1995), inspired from the natural sciences and supposedly free of the ideological presuppositions of economic theory contributed to make labor economics even more political than it was before.
Area:
Keywords: History of economics; Labor economics; Minimum Wage; Experimental method
Please Login in order to download this file