Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Capitalism in America: Tocqueville, Chevalier, Say

Paikin Teddy, McGill University

This paper analyzes how early nineteenth-century French political economists conceptualized American capitalism and the basis of its economic dynamism. French depictions of the American model varied depending on the economic strategies favored at home. Representations of U.S. capitalism became an ideological battleground between liberals and statists on the ideal shape of French economic development. Liberals like Jean-Baptiste Say, Charles Coquelin and Alexis de Tocqueville argued that America was flourishing because of its entrepreneurial spirit and free political institutions. As opposed to a France characterized by excessive state regulations, corporate organizations of labour and administrative centralization, America was the promised land of laissez-faire and the minimal state. Statist engineers like Guillaume Tell Poussin and Saint-Simonians like Adolphe Blanqui and Michel Chevalier, on the other hand, argued that state intervention was central to American economic dynamism. Sent on a mission to investigate the role of the state in organizing American railroad construction in 1834, Chevalier forcefully rejected laissez-faire representations of American capitalism by putting the “internal improvement” of state-level governments front and centre in his economic analysis. The “police powers” of state governments - conscious development policy - and not just private entrepreneurship, was crucial to American economic dynamism. Returning to Chevalier’s interpretation of U.S. capitalism serves to undermine the stereotypical representations of early nineteenth century France as naturally characterized by a Colbertist dirigisme and the United States as a laissez-faire paradise. On the contrary, Chevalier argued that France needed to learn from America’s interventionist political economy to overcome the limits imposed by Say’s influential laissez-faire economics and inform a programme for state-led economic development. A small point: I am only available to present with the American economic thought panel on 26-27. I have obligations in Paris on the 28th. Thank you for accommodating my request.

Area:

Keywords: economic development; capitalism; France; industrial policy; state intervention