Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Christianizing Capitalism’. The Moral Limits of Market-Reforms under Augusto Pinochet’s Dictatorship (1973-1990)

Jara Maximiliano, Freie Universität Berlin

The market-oriented reforms implemented by Chicago-trained economists during Augusto Pinochet’s dictatorship (1973–1990) positioned Chile as an emblematic case of “neoliberal transformation” in the late twentieth century. Specialized scholarship has made important contributions to understanding the introduction of market-oriented ideas in Chile, the role of the “Chicago Boys” in implementing economic reforms, and their socioeconomic consequences. Yet the moral challenges that market-driven capitalism faced in the country—and the responses formulated by market-oriented elites—remain understudied. Widespread human rights violations, conservative but anti-capitalist views, and the social costs of market reforms fueled the Catholic Church’s resistance to the regime, as many church actors described market capitalism as “amoral” and incompatible with the Church’s social doctrine. Catholic criticism, coupled with the reforms’ lack of democratic legitimacy, exposed the political and moral limits of market capitalism, an issue that concerned civilian allies of the regime. This presentation analyzes how Chilean market-oriented actors—including think tanks, intellectuals, and economists—addressed these tensions. It argues that they sought to construct an intellectual synthesis between Christian moral values and market-driven capitalist principles, relying on transnational networks that included figures in the United States, such as Michael Novak, as well as Argentine followers of the Austrian School of Economics. By examining the “Christianization of capitalism” in the Andean country, the presentation reflects on the cultural limits of market transformation, and it highlights the contextual challenges faced by economic theories with universal pretensions. In doing so, it sheds light on the adaptation of neoliberalism in Latin America, a region deeply shaped by cultural Catholicism. Methodologically, the presentation adopts a transnational intellectual history approach, drawing on primary sources from the Center for Public Studies, the Jaime Guzmán Foundation, interviews, press articles, journal publications, and specialized literature.

Area:

Keywords: Catholicism, Neoliberalism, Michael Novak, Austrian School, Transnational History, Chile

Please Login in order to download this file