Productivity Growth in the History of Economic Analysis
This paper traces the evolution of the concept of productivity and its growth in the history of economic analysis, from the First Industrial Revolution to contemporary debates on automation and artificial intelligence. It argues that productivity has never been a purely technical ratio of inputs to outputs, but has always reflected deeper social, institutional, and technological dynamics. Throughout the history of economic thought, productivity growth has been associated both with the promise of rising living standards and with concerns about distribution, employment, and social stability. The paper begins with the First Industrial Revolution, when sustained productivity growth emerged as a defining feature of modern economic development and posed new theoretical and empirical challenges. Classical economists placed productivity at the centre of their analyses: Adam Smith emphasized the division of labour, knowledge, and organization as sources of rising productive power, while David Ricardo distinguished between different forms of technological change and explicitly addressed the possibility of technological unemployment. Their framework linked productivity growth to changes in income distribution via the wage-profit relationship. Karl Marx inherited and transformed classical political economy by embedding productivity growth in a historical critique of capitalism. For Marx, productivity-enhancing, labour-saving innovations were driven by the search for relative surplus value and generated both material abundance and structural contradictions, including crises and the formation of a reserve army of labour. Joseph Schumpeter, by contrast, interpreted productivity growth as the outcome of entrepreneurial innovation and “creative destruction,” emphasizing discontinuous change, long waves, and the role of finance in enabling technological breakthroughs. The marginalist and neoclassical traditions largely sidelined the problem of productivity growth by treating technology as exogenously given. This culminated in Robert Solow’s growth accounting framework, where productivity appears as an unexplained residual. While this approach established productivity growth as the main driver of long-run economic growth, it offered little insight into its causes. Keynesian and Post-Keynesian economists reintroduced endogeneity by linking productivity growth to effective demand, expectations, investment, income distribution, and institutions, highlighting cumulative and path-dependent growth processes. Endogenous growth theories later sought to formalize innovation and knowledge accumulation within optimization frameworks. The paper concludes by reflecting on persistent measurement problems, sustainability constraints, and the relevance of historical insights for understanding productivity growth in the digital and AI-driven economy. It argues for a historically informed and pluralistic approach to productivity that integrates technical change with social and institutional analysis.
Area:
Keywords: Productivity; Industrial Revolution; Technological change; Classical political economy; Marx; Schumpeter; Solow; Growth accounting;
Please Login in order to download this file