Saint-Chamans's (1777-1860) Economic Thought: an Ultra-Royalist approach to Protectionism during the French Restoration (1815-1830)
At the outset of the Bourbon Restoration (1815-1830), the ultraroyalists, in concert with manufacturers, reshaped France's customs system, turning it into a strictly protectionists one (Démier, 2022). Until then, the French nobility had largely been influenced by physiocratic ideas that favored free-trade. This article examines the reasons behind nobility's shift from physiocratic free-trade toward protectionism, focusing on the economic thought of Auguste Louis-Philippe, vicomte de Saint-Chamans (1777-1860), an ultraroyalist deputy. Studies in the history of French economic thought during the Restoration have tended to center on Jean-Baptiste Say (1767-1832), while scholarship on protectionism has mainly focused on Friedrich List (1789-1846). Recent research has presented French protectionist ideas as one of the intellectual sources that may have inspired List (Helleiner, 2021, p. ; Suesse, 2023, p. ). Within French protectionism itself, historians of economic thought distinguish two main strands. An industrialist on, represented by Jean-Antoine Chaptal (1756-1832), Charles Dupin (1784-1873), and Charles Ganilh (1758-1836). And a neo-mercantilist one, including François Louis Auguste Ferrier (1777-1861), Vincent-Marie Viénot de Vaublanc (1756-1845), and Saint-Chamans. Yet Saint-Chamans can not be reduced to a simple neo-mercantilist. His analysis of protectionism attributes a specific economic role to the nobility. Grounding his theory of value in consumption, he argues that value remains purely potential until the good is sold; only consumption realizes it, thereby contributing to national wealth. Luxury consumption thus become a social duty for the nobility, while saving saving destroys value, occuruing at the expense of consumption. Because of the nobility can choose between luxury spending and saving, its behavior determines whether economic growth prevails or a crisis of overproduction arises from insufficient demand. Building on this conception, Saint-Chamans advocates protectionist policies to safeguard the interests of national producers and, by extension, the economic function of the nobility. Protectionism, according to him, should grant domestic producers a monopoly over the national market, by restricting the import of foreign raw materials. It also seeks to prevent distorsions between sectors: cotton manufacturing, based on imported raw materials and mechanization, threatened to displace the traditional production of wool and linen, which relied on domestic inputs and manual labor, with few mechanization. Saint-Chamans's protectionism therefore goes beyond industrial or neo-mercantilist reasoning, expressing a distinctly ultraroyalist conception of economic order. This vision, shared by fellow deputies and thinkers, such as Louis de Bonald (1754-1840), illustrates the existence of an ultraroyalist strand of protectionism. For these thinkers, protectionism was not merely an instrument of national industry, but a means of secucring noble incomes– seen as essential to the proper functionning of the economy.
Area:
Keywords: French protectionists ; commercial policy ; infant-industry argument ; prohibitive system
Please Login in order to download this file