Thin Wallet, Broad Prosperity? Back to the Origins of the French and Belgian Monetary Levy (1941–1945)
In 1944, France and Belgium were in a catastrophic situation. The war had two major consequences for both countries: first, a considerable decline in national income; second, a substantial increase in the money supply. This expansion was sterilized, with varying degrees of effectiveness, through the implementation of a strict policy of price controls and rationing. To prevent uncontrolled inflation at the time of liberation, Pierre Mendès France (France) and Camille Gutt (Belgium) proposed similar plans involving a drastic reduction in their countries’ money supply. Upon liberation, all banknotes were to be demonetized, and citizens would be invited to exchange their old notes for a smaller amount of new ones. The difference would be placed in a blocked account, thereby sterilizing excess purchasing power. The attempted implementation of the Mendès France plan has been the subject of extensive literature in economic history (Kuisel, 1984; Margairaz, 1991; Chélini, 1998; Bloch Lainé and Bouvier, 1986; Bouvier, 1974), while the Gutt operation has received a relatively recent reassessment (Van der Wee and Verbreyt, 2009). Yet these monetary projects have been only marginally studied from the perspective of the history of economic thought, even though they constitute unique indicators of francophone economists’ thinking and of the monetary controversies of their time. This article seeks to address this gap. It examines the projects of Mendès France and Gutt from the standpoint of the historian of economic thought, with the aim of tracing the theoretical influences that led to the formulation of similar policies in two different countries. In doing so, it analyzes the ideas of the economists involved in the design of these projects by reconstructing the monetary theories underlying these particular proposals.
Area:
Keywords: Pierre Mendès France; Camille Gutt, Monetary Levy, World War Two