The Viennese Mises on Interventionism
The claim that mixed economies are inherently instable, is a recurring theme in Ludwig von Mises’ writings. In short, he asserts that state intervention into an economy based on private property leads either towards complete socialism or calls for a complete “return” to the free market by upending all government interventions. This paper is not primarily concerned with the development of the Misesian theory of interventionism, but rather addresses the question whether Mises’ critique of interventionism really equates to the formulation of a coherent theory proving the impossibility of a stable mixed economy. I suggest that Mises was aware that a certain kind of mixed economy could ultimately be stable: First, there are challenges to his claim that are directly related to his definition of intervention, which excludes „ measures taken for the purpose of maintaining and securing the private ownership of the means of production“ and „socialization of parts of the means of production“ (Mises 1929, p.4). Second, Mises refers at times to the relative differences in the extent to which interventions disturb the proper functioning of markets and thus allows for a potential relative stability of some policies. Third, Mises acknowledges that the market process is adaptable enough to function around some interventions and thus making the persistence of the system of private property possible. The paper suggests thus that Mises motivates his argument for the instability of the hampered economy not exclusively on the basis of tendencies inherent to interventions, as it is oftentimes portrayed, but more importantly on the basis of the incentive structure faced by politicians in a system where economic policy-making is subject to democratic legitimacy.
Area:
Keywords: Ludwig Mises, Interventionism, Economic Policy, Democracy
Please Login in order to download this file