Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

The blind spot of catholic neoliberal economic thought: Götz Briefs and the history of the German welfare state.

Plehwe Dieter, WZB Berlin Social Science Center

Research on varieties of capitalism and welfare states has emphasized as strong role of religion for the differences between countries. For Germany, a country with two major churches – protestant and catholic – an interdenominational compromise between welfare state skeptical (Lutheran) Protestants and generous Catholicism has been argued by Manow (2008). Both tendencies were important within the ruling Christian Democratic party during the post-war era important to the building of the German welfare state. The close link between Protestantism and Germany’s major neoliberal economic orientation, ordoliberalism, explains the relevance of this group for the early concept of Ludwig Erhard’s social market economy, which needed to get along with catholic social teaching relevant to the labor and corporatist wings of the post-war Christian Democratic parties. Contrary to this argument of an interdenominational compromise it is necessary to shed more light on the divisions within the denominations. A catholic neoliberal wing of high relevance to the post-war constellation has been overlooked so far. While Götz Briefs and his catholic neoliberal allies did not succeed in the effort to reinforce the (ordoliberal) opposition to Germany’s public pension system, the recognition of Briefs’s catholic neoliberal economic ideas helps to better explain the ways in which Germany’s social market economy and welfare state rested on a political compromise than unitarian perspectives of the denominations. Due to the relevance of the history of catholic social teaching in Germany a closer reading of catholic neoliberalism in Germany also helps to better explain the evolution and diffusion of neoliberalism in the predominantly catholic hemisphere in Latin America and elsewhere.

Area:

Keywords: Götz Briefs, Economics, Catholicism, Neoliberalism, Third Way