Assisting the invalid poor: Physiocratic economic reasoning and the rationalisation of poor relief
This article analyses how French Physiocratic economists in the second half of the eighteenth century conceptualised assistance to the invalid poor. Drawing on recent historiographical renewals in the study of poverty and relief policies in the early modern period (Cochon 2011; Fontaine 2022; Pertué 2023; Skornicki 2023, 2024), it highlights a structured economic reflection on poor relief that goes beyond the common-sense opposition between charity and liberalism. Two main findings emerge from this study. The first demonstrates the influence of Nicolas Baudeau on the Physiocratic understanding of poverty. Building on the work of Clément (2008, 2010, 2015), a close analysis of Baudeau’s 1765 treatise, Idées d’un citoyen sur les besoins, les droits et les devoirs des vrais pauvres, shows that he developed a systematic reflection on assistance to the invalid poor. His discussions of orphans and the disabled were unprecedented within the Physiocratic corpus. Moreover, several of his recommendations were widely taken up and debated by Mirabeau, Dupont, Turgot, and Le Trosne in the Éphémérides du Citoyen. These exchanges allow us to regard these proposals as representative of Physiocratic thought on poverty and assistance in the 1760s. The second finding highlights the economic principles underlying these proposals. The economists under study advocated an organisation of poor relief aimed at limiting its economic and social costs, particularly the risks of work disincentives, abuses associated with so-called “false poor,” and the excessive expenditures generated by large hospital institutions considered both luxurious and inefficient. Drawing on Joël’s (1984) methodology, we show that Baudeau and Dupont relied on cost–benefit analysis to demonstrate the superiority of home-based relief over hospitalisation for the sick poor. With regard to children, persons with disabilities, and the elderly, we argue that Baudeau, Turgot, Mirabeau, and Dupont defended a form of assistance strictly targeted at the “deserving poor” and their actual needs. In this perspective, past, present, or future labour constituted an essential counterpart to receiving assistance, revealing a conception of poverty in which invalidity did not preclude all forms of productive participation. By highlighting this articulation between economic efficiency, social justice, and work incentives, this article contributes to a better understanding of Physiocratic thought, in which assistance to the poor was framed in relation to the theoretical principles of economic liberalism.
Area:
Keywords: Baudeau, Physiocrats, Benevolence, Invalid poor, Poor relief
Please Login in order to download this file