Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

The Structural Roots of Instability: Analytical Steps in Linear Multi-Sectoral Dynamics (1948–1952)

Assous Michaël, Université Lumière Lyon 2
Alain Raybaut, Unive

This paper examines three pivotal analytical steps—contributed by David Hawkins (1948), Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen, and Robert Solow (1952)—that fundamentally reshaped the understanding of economic dynamics and instability within the linear multi-sectoral framework between the late 1940s and the early 1950s. While some developments were independent, these advancements were largely intertwined with the intellectual environment of the Harvard Economic Research Project (HERP), directed by Wassily Leontief. The first key step is Hawkins' 1948 independent contribution to macroeconomic stability. Employing a multi-dimensional system of ordinary differential equations with an accelerator-like investment mechanism, Hawkins pioneered a structural approach. His modeling emphasized the economy’s technical coefficient matrix as the source of endogenous growth instability, concluding that stability hinges on the "dynamical coupling" between sectors—a requirement he termed "close coupling" in two-sector models. Critically, Hawkins defined stability not as a traditional dynamic adjustment process, but as the capacity for a feasible exponential growth path where transient solutions decay relative to the normal growth rate. The second crucial step involves Georgescu-Roegen’s work during his association with HERP, focusing on a rigorous mathematical extension and critique of Leontief’s dynamic input-output model. Georgescu-Roegen challenged the model's inability to capture business cycle phenomena due to assumptions of constant proportionality, introducing the concept of relaxation phenomena—dynamic movements characterized by discontinuous regimes and asymmetric periodicity—as essential for modeling economic cycles. He demonstrated that Leontief’s attempt to incorporate turning-point discontinuity via changing investment coefficients was insufficient. Instead, Georgescu-Roegen proposed the concept of phase-periodicity (recurrence of phases rather than constant repetition of values) and explicitly linked the multi-sectoral Leontief structure to the macrodynamic framework of Samuelson (1939) and Hansen (1941). The third step is Solow’s 1952 synthesis, influenced by his work at HERP and collaboration with Samuelson. Solow provided a formal mathematical demonstration of the profound connection between multi-sector multiplier models and input-output analysis, revealing their shared underlying linear algebraic structures. His synthesis clarified the critical link between the existence of an economically relevant static solution and the stability of the corresponding dynamic system. Building upon Hawkins’ qualitative insights, Solow utilized mathematical rigor to reinforce the central role of the technical coefficient matrix, arguing that dynamic stability depends on the inherent coupling of stable and unstable sectoral elements. Taken together, these three lines of research mark a singular, foundational episode in post-World War II macroeconomics. By focusing on structural stability criteria, the nature of dynamic economic oscillations, and the mathematical unification of multi-sectoral approaches, this work fundamentally redefined how economic instability was analyzed, paving the way for the later development of the neoclassical growth model.

Area:

Keywords: History of macroeconomics, instability, multi-sector models

Please Login in order to download this file