Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Modern Sino-German Interaction in Economic Thought: Based on Investigation of the Journal Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv

Wang Fan, Zhongnan University of Economics and Law

In the global history of economic thought, German economic theory has a noteworthy place. The intellectual framework of the German Historical School served as a crucial source of economic ideas for China’s early economic modernization. This paper examines Sino-German economic thought interactions within the international political-economic context during the Republic of China, using materials from a German academic journal, Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, which was established by the Kiel Institute for the World Economy. The Kiel Institute for the World Economy has existed for more than 100 years, tracing its origins to a national scientific research seminar established at Kiel University in 1899. It looks back on a rich and changeful history in which the scientific work was always oriented toward political movements and the global economic challenges of each era. Since its foundation the institute has had a strong reputation in the international scientific community. This reputation was lost temporarily during the time the institute was in service of the National Socialist regime. Review of World Economics is the official publication of the Kiel Institute for the World Economy. Founded in 1913 as the world’s first journal in international economics under the name Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, the Review has retained this focus, with particular emphasis on research in global supply chains and monetary and fiscal policies in open economies. The Review published 63 volumes between its founding in 1913 and 1949, many of which included articles about contemporary Chinese economics. These articles covered a wide range of topics, including the labor economy, foreign trade, banking, transportation, postal services, industrialization, and agriculture in modern China. In modern times, the achievement of industrialization stood as the most crucial theme in the Nanjing Nationalist Government’s policies. Chinese industrialization studies were the focus of a special issue of the Review in 1937, which featured the opinions and viewpoints of notable academics and Chinese economic officials. The Review’s initiative was not coincidental; rather, it resulted from the special circumstances of Sino-German relations at the time. Following World War I, the Treaty of Versailles placed restrictions on Germany. Trade relations between China and Germany started to transition from an unequal colonial-colonial relationship to one based on equality. Meanwhile, the Nanjing Nationalist Government regarded Germany as a model for economic development. On May 20, 1921, China and Germany signed the Sino-German Agreement in Beijing. Germany renounced all privileges in modern China and explicitly recognized the tariff autonomy of both nations. This treaty was regarded as one of the rare equal treaties that China concluded with Western powers in modern history. From March to June 1930, a delegation from “Reichsverbandes der deutschen Industrie” visited several Chinese provinces and cities to gather firsthand information on modern China’s economic conditions and explore feasible cooperation projects with the Chinese government. In January the following year, the “Reichsverbandes der deutschen Industrie” established the “China-Studienkommission” with the stated purpose of “studying China’s industrialization issues and making necessary preparations in collaboration with all relevant organizations.” In June 1937, H. H. Kung, the finance minister of the Nanjing Nationalist Government, led a delegation to Germany. Strengthening Sino-German industrial exchange was one of the key tasks of this delegation. Regarding this incident, the Review featured a special issue titled “Development, Status, and Prospects—China’s Industrialization” in Volume 45. Using this material, this paper studies the influence of political factors on the interaction of modern Sino-German economic thought.

Area:

Keywords: Modern Chinese Industrialization, Sino-German Relations, Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, Worldwide Economic Thought and Civilization

Please Login in order to download this file