Turgot’s Réflexions sur la formation et la distribution des richesses in its contemporary intellectual context
Turgot’s Reflections on the formation and distribution of wealth, written by November 1766, has often been considered as a detached exercise in pure economic theory whose brilliance sets it apart from the works of any of his contemporaries. In his short treatise, Turgot argues that in a freely competitive economy there is a tendency towards ‘a kind of equilibrium’ between the money rate of interest and the returns obtainable in employments of capital in all commercial enterprises and in the purchase of land. In addition, he outlines a theory of capital accumulation that closely related savings to productive investments. While the undoubted relevance for subsequent developments in economy theory has gained Turgot’s contribution a deservedly high, post-humous, reputation, this paper considers the text in its contemporary context. What had been Turgot’s intentions in writings the text? This question can be answered by taking into account the political and economic debates of the mid-1760s. After the conclusion of the Seven Years’ War in 1763, broadly two visions for France’s economic revival came to oppose each other. On the one hand, there were authors who advocated that France should emulate the commercial and financial policies of its successful rival, Britain. This involved policies to revive and protect France’s mercantile navy and the trade with its colonies, and to develop public credit in the ways Britain had done. On the other hand, there were authors who argued that France should withdraw from ‘jealous’ mercantile policies that could only lead to further military confrontation and instead focus on domestic growth, by creating conditions for a more efficient agriculture which would be an engine for general economic activity and prosperity. The significance of the confrontation between these two visions, which heated up in the economic journals in the period 1764-1767, is that Turgot had intellectual ties with both camps. Amongst the first were authors like Montaudouin and Forbonnais, who had belonged to the so-called Gournay Circle, with which Turgot had been associated from the mid-1750s. The other camp followed the lead of Quesnay and formed a closely-knit group of économistes, with whom Turgot had been conversant since the late 1750s. Despite its apparent detached tone and subject matter, the Reflections can be seen as Turgot’s effort to take position in these debates. Rather than attempting a mere reconciliation of positions, Turgot went back to ‘first principles’ or, as he describes it, an outline of the ‘natural order of things’. This allowed him to extend Quesnay’s conceptions of the economy as a single system of economic reproduction by integrating and transforming arguments about the importance of the various returns on capital investments and the importance of (low) interest rates, which had figured in publications of the authors that had been tutored by Gournay. The impression of a detached economic treatise is preserved by the avoidance of political implications, such as taxation policies, public credit, and colonial policies (which Turgot did, however, address in other writings). Setting Turgot’s in the intellectual context of its time, provides a more historical understanding of the author’s intentions than the conventional view that he somehow perceived the emergence of a ‘capitalist economy’ and that his Reflections should be seen as a strictly economic-analytical performance that constitutes a stage between the theories of Quesnay and Smith.
Area:
Keywords: Turgot, Gournay, Quesnay, Forbonnais, political economy
Please Login in order to download this file