Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Assessing the limits of the government in political economy in mid-19th century Spain. The ideas of Andrés Borrego

San Julian Arrupe Javier, University of Barcelona

The mid decades of the 19th century witnessed the long process of the creation of the liberal state in Spain, marked by political instability, upheavals and short-lived constitutions. Within this context, political economy consolidated itself as a valuable field of knowledge capable of fostering the country’s prosperity. Debates arose on the scope of political economy and the role of the government. It is within this framework that the figure of Andrés Borrego (1802-1891) emerged. A journalist and economist, and politically a moderate, Borrego reflected on the intervention of the State in some crucial episodes for the Spanish economy, offering insight into the tensions between political economy and politics. Borrego’s early critiques of the design and outcome of the 1836 disentailment of Church property reveal his concern with the political misuse of economic reforms. He lamented that the sale of nationalized real state represented a lost opportunity both to use the proceeds to promote agriculture’s development through education and credit, and to address, at least partially, Spain’s enduring problem of public debt. He also criticized the mismanagement of the abolition of the tithe, another missed opportunity to strengthen government revenues. The fiasco of this operation would leave a long-lasting impression on him. More significant are Borrego’s reflections on the problem of tariff reform and on the scope of government’s intervention in such an issue in his Principles of political economy (1844). Here Borrego argued that political economy should follow the German approach of the Nationalökonomie, a science concerned with the welfare of citizens and society, connecting the interest of the State and the people. Political economy, in his view, should not be theoretical, but essentially a practical, empirical science. Individual interest as a stimulus to competition needed to be restrained to limit unfair distribution, capital destruction and low wages. These concerns were particularly evident in the tariff issue. It is here that Borrego supported limited intervention of the government with a twofold objective: protecting industry and addressing public needs. Although he acknowledged that the doctrine of government intervention required further development, Borrego considered intervention compulsory as the State had the obligation to protect freedom and equality among citizens, and because there could not exist any economic matter in which the State influence should not be an element, through legislation or through effective intervention to preserve the harmony of interests. His list of the duties of the government was long, ranging from providing public education to harmonizing social interests. Nevertheless, tariffs became Borrego’s primary battlefield, where he contested the classical economists’ arguments in favour of free trade and defended the legitimacy of government action to protect the nation’s economy. His last topic where he confronted the decisions of the Spanish government, developed in his work of 1877, Principles of public economics, concerned public debt and credit, where he sustained the idea that only the State should be entitled to issue legal tender. Borrego’s sustained questioning of the role of the government illustrates the tension between political power and political economy during the crucial period of the building of modern liberal states and the ensuing debates on defining the proper economic functions of the State.

Area:

Keywords: economic policy, government intervention, protectionism, disentailment.

Please Login in order to download this file