The Rarity of Reswitching Within Technology Sets. A Proposal to Meet Professor Petri’s Objections
Professor Fabio Petri honours me with a further critical paper on my attempt to shift the focus of the Cambridge critique of capital from the reswitching debate to a more direct critique of the neoclassical substitution mechanism. I start with a survey of the state of the discussion (Section 1). I continue with replying first to his negative criticisms and I then take up the ones that I regard as positive and constructive (Section 2). Reswitching and reverse capital deepening lead to a decisive critique of neoclassical theory only if the probability of their occurrence is sufficiently high. To meet his constructive criticisms, I propose to modify my definition of reswitching and reverse capital deepening (RCD) in Section 3 by introducing convex technology sets, mostly spanned by a finite number of elementary production methods. This represents a novel contribution to the theory. I had introduced such technology sets fifty years earlier in order to show that the probability is positive for systems of finite order, but I had not noticed that this probability diminishes rapidly, if the order of the system increases. I showed in recent papers that the probability tends to zero for larger and larger systems, but I neglected certain special properties of the techniques such as the realistic condition that all methods to produce a commodity may need the same raw material ("no bread without flour"). This gap, criticised by Petri, has now been closed, using the older approach. It turns out that my fundamental conclusions remain unchanged.
Area:
Keywords: capital theory, long-period prices, reswitching, Sraffa, probability
Please Login in order to download this file