Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Value and Distribution in Adam Smith's Theoretical Machinery

Smith Matthew, University of Sydney

In celebration of the 250-year anniversary of the publication of Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations (1776) this paper in concerned with clarifying the general structure of its theoretical machinery which links the analysis of value and distribution predominant in Book I with the analysis of economic growth predominant in Book II. Our central focus will be on Smith’s theory of prices and distribution and how it is conceived to contribute to economic growth and how, in turn, growth is conceived to causally influence prices and distribution within a coherent dynamic analytical system of economic thought – which we can call his theoretical machinery. This exposition begins in Section 2 by considering Smith’s position on the division of aggregate income between wage, profit, and rent shares and how it relates to his theory of capital accumulation. Then, in Section 3 we consider Smith’s position on value theory and his approach to explaining prices. Section 4 critically examines Smith’s ‘adding-up’ approach to explaining the determination of natural prices of commodities. It involves an exposition of Smith’s explanation of natural prices by reference to the determination of their costs of production according to how the values of the distributive variables – the wage rate on labour, the profit rate on capital and the rent on land – are explained, for a given system wide technique of production. In Section 5 we examine Smith’s analysis of the determination of prices and outputs in connection to the allocation of resources in a decentralized capitalist economic system. Section 6 considers Smith’s conception of competition and its two dimensions in the role it plays in Smith’s theory of prices, distribution and growth. In Section 7 the relationship between Smith’s dynamic growth analysis and his analysis of prices and distribution is considered as a unified theoretical machinery, showing how it supports his policy proposals in the WN to promote growth and economic development. The conclusion in Section 8 provides an evaluation of Smith’s theoretical machinery with a focus on the legacy of his theory of prices and distribution.

Area:

Keywords: Aam Smith; classical economics; classical theory of value and distribution

Please Login in order to download this file