Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Early Scottish banking controversy

Ito Seiichiro, Ohtsuki City College

Monetary and financial events during the decades following the establishment of the Bank of England have been widely and deeply studied as the part of the dawn of modern banking and public finance both. However, those studies have usually focused on the function of the brand-new credit system and the building of the financial market, calling the whole evolving process the financial revolution, but they have not paid enough attention to what the creators of the system sought and what the issues were in their discussions. In England and Irland the biggest concerns of the proposers of credit systems, particularly banks, were the reliability, reputation and safety of the proposed organization. They thought that without reliability any credit project would not be successful. It was not an exclusively economic matter but a rather moral and social one. What I address here is on the Scottish case. It was not a simple copy of the English version. William Paterson, born in southern Scotland, Dumfriesshire, has been well known as a founder of the Bank of England. However, he has been sometimes sarcastically mentioned as a fickle and frivolous projector. Indeed, his proposition of the fund for the orphans and his promotion of so-called Darien scheme made him appear ambitious or unreliable. He was also involved in the discussions about the establishment and management of the Bank of Scotland. Then his figure has tended to be described as not worth an essential figure in the history of banking. Nevertheless, whether he was so or not, it is worth reexamining what he intended in his projects when one should know what the issue was in the discussions in his days and what his contemporary projectors thought essential for the construction of a good credit system. This paper tries to find out not how the credit system was built in early modern Scotland but what kind of system the people strive to construct there by tracing the discussions on paper, particularly concerning the Bank of Scotland and the Royal Bank of Scotland, among projectors such as William Paterson, John Holland and James Armour.

Area:

Keywords: Scotland banking 18th century

Please Login in order to download this file