Smith’s evolutionary story versus Polanyi’s Great Transformation
In his seminal book from 1944, Polanyi’s provides a depressing account of a disintegrating society under the hammers of capitalism and markets. Reciprocal relationships have been reduced into commercial exchanges leaving individuals alienated and lonely. But this sounds very similar to Smith’s vision of a society where mutual assistance is based on mercenary relationships. The almost two hundred years which separate them may suggest that Polanyi’s explanation—clearly influenced by the tumultuous experience of the 19th century— is not the only one and perhaps, not even the right one. In Polanyi’s account one cannot escape the feeling that here we have people who have become victims of a vicious system that ruined their own conception of a naturally harmonious society. But would not these very same people be the cause of these ruinous institutions? By suggesting that the solution to this problem is socialism, Polanyi again seems to ignore the fact that no social institutions can subsist for too long without a degree of consent and acceptance—be it misguided in the eyes of some or not— by the public. For Adam Smith, on the other hand, morality and social norms—and hence, institutions—are endogenous and therefore, the question is not which institutions have been imposed on the public and whether there are better ones to be imposed but rather, how did society end up with certain institutions and how can a change be brought about. Smith would certainly agree with the way Polanyi describes society and the fact that these ailments are still upon us may suggest that Polanyi’s prescriptive approach was misguided. Therefore, I will use Smith’s notions of relative and endogenous morality to show that the reason why society fell into the rut of alienation and loneliness is due to the corruption of moral sentiments through the commercialisation of social and moral values which led to a corrupt social system. I will endeavour to show that the pursuit of social approbation led to the abandonment of the human dimension of society for an economic conception of it. Neither capitalism nor socialism provide a remedy to the loss of humanity in the conception of society which paved the way for a corrupt and commercialised morality. The remedy, which Smith does not offer, will have to be in finding the institutional arrangement that preserves the true nature of the way in which morality and social norms are created.
Area:
Keywords: Adam Smith, Polanyi, Great Transformation, Ethics, Social Evolution, Institutions
Please Login in order to download this file