Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Endogenous Growth Theory in Thomas Robert Malthus

Wakamatsu Naoyuki, Chuo university

In the theory of economic growth, Paul Romer’s paper, “Increasing Returns and Long-run Growth” (1986, Journal of Political Economy), marked a major turning point. Endogenous growth theory is often associated with increasing returns to scale. However, the core insight lies in the idea that technological progress generated through learning and R&D, accompanying increases in capital and population, can offset diminishing returns and sustain long-run economic growth even under constant returns to scale. Notably, the essence of endogenous growth bears a deep analogy to the classical theory of economic growth. David Ricardo, for instance, described a stationary state as a result of diminishing returns, where the expansion of the economy would cease. At the same time, he acknowledged the possibility that an economy could, in reality, grow sustainably through endogenous technological improvements associated with population growth. Nevertheless, Ricardo did not clearly specify whether such improvements could continue to outweigh diminishing returns. In this respect, this study argues that Thomas Robert Malthus can be regarded as the first economist to provide endogenous growth theory in the classical framework. According to Waterman (2012: “Adam Smith and Malthus on High Wages,” EJHET, 19(3)), while Malthus recognized the possibility of endogenous technological progress, he did not incorporate this idea into his analytical framework. However, a close reading of Section 3 of Chapter 5 of Principles of Political Economy (1820) reveals that Malthus considered an endogenous growth mechanism from the point of view of excess profits, and he seems to have applied the idea into his analysis of general gluts. Therefore, we demonstrate that an endogenous growth theory within the classical framework was present in Malthus, providing a theoretical explanation of general gluts under conditions of constant returns to scale. The analysis is conducted using the Malthusian model developed by Dome (1992: Kotenkeizaigaku no Mokeibunseki [Classical Economics: Modeling Analysis]. Tokyo: Yuhikaku, in Japanese).

Area:

Keywords: Thomas Robert Malthus; Paul Romer; endogenous growth

Please Login in order to download this file