Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

A Third Way Against Poverty: Atkinson’s Road to the Participation Income

Jacob Eva, BETA, University of Strasbourg

This article reconstructs the intellectual trajectory that led British economist Anthony B. Atkinson to propose the participation income as a third way between social insurance and basic income in the fight against poverty. Before the 1990s, Atkinson adopted a cautious analytical stance, assessing both approaches without publicly endorsing either, while displaying a preference for the Beveridgean model. We identify three factors that led him to move beyond this opposition in the early 1990s: the normative shift of the Thatcher era, which rendered the unconditionality of transfers politically untenable, the work of Hermione Parker, which introduces for the first time the feasibility of a complementarity between social insurance and basic income, and the new European institutional context emerging from the Maastricht Treaty, which transformed this complementarity from a theoretical option into a structural necessity. Atkinson's shift from a cautious evaluative posture to an original prescriptive proposal thus represents the culmination of a tension present since the late 1960s, which these three factors ultimately led him to resolve through the participation income.

Area:

Keywords: Basic income; inequalities; poverty; political feasibility; UK context

Please Login in order to download this file