Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Hayek with Kant: Epistemological Limits and the Aesthetic Structure of Economic Judgment

Erber Pedro, Waseda University

What if economic expertise and the political authority attached to it rested on a mode of cognition and valuation structurally akin to aesthetic judgment? This paper revisits Friedrich Hayek’s account of market coordination through the lens of Kantian aesthetics to argue that both thinkers confront a shared problem: how order becomes intelligible at the limits of human knowledge. I show that they arrive at parallel solutions to the problem of spontaneous order, relying on forms of knowledge irreducible to conceptual mastery. Their convergence reveals a largely unacknowledged grammar of cognition that both enables market coordination and shapes the political authority and intrinsic limits of economic reasoning. Central to Hayek’s work is the claim that economic agents act under fundamental ignorance, guided less by concepts than by fragmentary informational signals. He accordingly reframes economics around the partial, dispersed character of knowledge. The price system, in this light, functions not as a calculative device but as a perceptual interface through which agents navigate a world they can never fully articulate. The resulting market order emerges, in Hayek’s words, as “quasi-teleological”—coherent in appearance despite the absence of intention or overarching design. This tension between order and ignorance has profound political consequences: it sets limits on what economics can credibly claim to know, justify, or govern. Kant’s Critique of Judgment offers a revealing parallel. Aesthetic judgment arises when sensible particulars appear as if purposively arranged, though no determinate concept can secure this purposiveness. As Hannah Arendt observed, its appeal to a shared sensus communis models a form of political judgment grounded in a plurality of individuals acting together rather than in objective rules. My paper argues that Hayekian market theory reproduces this structure of purposiveness without purpose. Like Kant, Hayek describes forms of order that emerge below the threshold of conceptual determination and depend on sensorially mediated pattern-recognition that appears objective while resisting full articulation. Reading Hayek’s market theory along with Kant brings into view an aesthetic substrate of economic judgment, through which markets coordinate and from which economics derives a form of legitimacy irreducible to objective calculation. Attending to this foundation extends Hayek’s own critique of economic knowledge, prompting a reconsideration of the epistemic limits and political role of economic expertise and reframing the philosophical and political stakes of market liberalism.

Area:

Keywords: Hayek; epistemology; aesthetics; politics; Kant; market liberalism; spontaneous order