Competing visions of cronyism within the Virginia school of political economy
The growing entanglement between political and economic elites has fueled concerns about inequality, stagnation, and democratic erosion. Both critics of capitalism and classical liberal thinkers condemn the privileges and rent-seeking that arise in this context—but they diverge in their diagnosis. Critics see these outcomes as the result of capitalism. Classical liberals view them as a betrayal of capitalism’s core principles. This paradox raises two questions: first, does our current system truly reflect capitalism? And second, if not,what is the nature of our system and its relationship with capitalism? To explore these questions, we turn to the Virginia Political Economy (VPE) tradition, beginning with Buchanan, Tullock, and Tollison’s theory of rent-seeking. Following this line of inquiry, Randall Holcombe and Richard Wagner both argue that our current system is more accurately described as cronyism rather than capitalism. However, they differ in their analysis. Holcombe views cronyism as a distortion of Adam Smith’s system of natural liberty. In contrast, we interpret and extend Wagner’s entangled political economy framework in a way that suggests cronyism, rather than a deviation from capitalism, is an inherent feature of all economic systems. We argue that our interpretation of Wagner’s framework provides a superior lens for understanding cronyism for two reasons. First, it reframes the historical trajectory: the central tension across economic history is not capitalism versus socialism, but capitalism versus cronyism. Second, Wagner’s perspective better identifies the root cause of the problem. Capitalism, far from naturally degenerating into cronyism, is a fragile institutional achievement, in a perpetual tug-of-war against the persistent chains of cronyism.
Area:
Keywords: Virgina school of political economy; capitalism; cronyism; History of economic thought