Who Shapes Whom? The Role of the Economist in Statecraft
What is the role of the economist in state craftsmanship? Historians of neoliberalism often portray economists as masterminds behind a set of policies and institutional redesigns in a market-oriented direction. In these accounts, neoliberals, whether from the Geneva School or the public choice tradition, are held responsible for the reduction in the scope of the state and its “marketization.” Despite their differences, these narratives share one feature: the economist appears as the central protagonist in reshaping the state. In this paper we develop an alternative account. Drawing on the history of economic thought, the sociology of the economics profession, and the development of the social sciences more generally, we advance an endogeneity thesis: the increasing role of economists in statecraft is not a prior cause nor simply the result of economists’ plans, but rather a consequence of inherent changes in the needs, problems, and legitimation requirements of the state. We illustrate this argument through the case of the European Union. We show that the EU’s constitutional architecture arose primarily from legal, political, and diplomatic logics, and that economists entered EU policymaking relatively late, typically as specialised experts operating within frameworks they did not design. Our account nuances claims about the direct importance of economists in recent political and economic change and recasts them as embedded experts rather than grand architects of state-building. In doing so, it sheds new light on how economic ideas gain influence (or fail to do so) in processes of statecraft.
Area:
Keywords: History of Economic Thought; State-building; European Union; Neoliberalism
Please Login in order to download this file