Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Malthus and Mill on Public Debt

Zouboulakis Michel, University of Thessaly

The balanced budget was the canon for every Government until WWI at least. Classical Political Economists were, in general, against public funding of economic activity, although there was no unanimity among them. Thomas Malthus had strong views on public policy issues. His views on public resources and spending should be understood jointly with his idea of “effectual demand” and the problem of underconsumption that arises when the surplus of production is not invested but hoarded. Thus, he criticized both Hume and Smith for carrying more to handle public deficit through taxation and avoid sovereign bankruptcy, disregarding the need to boost the economy through public bonds bought by the rich. In his turn, John Stuart Mill recognized that governments often contend with extraordinary expenses and raise money through public borrowing. As with taxes, he believed that loans deprive capital of more productive uses. Unless “what is borrowed is foreign capital” or it concerns a capital that “would have been wasted in unproductive enterprises”, loans are an obstruction to the process of accumulation. Yet, Mill did try to reconsider the whole issue of public debt. Away from Ricardo's categorical rejection, he defined a criterion to assess debt sustainability and determine whether its limits have been exceeded. It seems then that Malthus and Mill were more flexible on the priority of a balanced budget, paving the way for Keynes in the next century, concerning the utility of public debt as a factor of growth.

Area:

Keywords: Thomas Malthus, John Stuart Mill, Public Finance, Economic Policy

Please Login in order to download this file