The Digital Euro from a Historical Perspective: The "Anchor Function" of a Central Bank Currency
This paper contextualizes one of the European Central Bank’s arguments for a digital euro within a historical framework: to maintain the euro as a monetary anchor. Public confidence in private money depends on its convertibility into central bank money at a one-to-one ratio. This conversion rate functions as the monetary anchor that ensures the currency's unity. The ECB fears that technological innovations, particularly distributed ledger–based private cryptocurrencies and stablecoins, could erode this anchor. This would weaken the two-tier monetary system and potentially generate currency fragmentation. Thus, the digital euro is presented as a conservative measure intended to preserve monetary sovereignty, protect the unit of account, and maintain the connection between central bank money and bank-issued credit money. To contextualize this argument, the paper revisits two historical episodes. First is Prussia’s attempt at “Reichstalerization” (1750–1755), an ambitious reform by Johann Philipp Graumann under Frederick II. Graumann tried to impose a uniform Reichstaler across the fragmented monetary landscape of the Holy Roman Empire. The Graumann reform aimed to stabilize and standardize debased Prussian coinage, limit the circulation of foreign currency, and increase fiscal seigniorage and geopolitical influence. Contemporary cameralist theorists, such as Johann Heinrich Gottlob Justi, condemned the fiscal exploitation of coinage. They insisted on a strict separation of monetary and fiscal aims and portrayed the state as the guardian of bona fide in currency matters. However, its failure demonstrates the limits of monetary unification without sufficient political authority, institutional coordination, and fiscal-monetary separation—conditions central to the credibility of any monetary anchor. This episode also illustrates the Gresham's law and the vulnerability of decentralized currency regimes to arbitrage and quality deterioration. The second historical perspective is the debate between the Currency School and the Banking School, which ended with the Bank Charter Act of 1844 in England. The Currency School advocated for rigid, gold-backed note issuance to ensure price stability. However, this approach limited liquidity during times of crisis. In contrast, the Banking School emphasized endogenous credit creation and real-bill financing, insisting that elasticity was essential for economic coordination. The 1844 law was one-sided, but later developments led to a compromise establishing a two-tiered system. In this system, the central bank provides stability, while commercial banks ensure the elastic provision of credit within the monetary system. Drawing on historical analogies, the paper posits that the ECB’s current preoccupation with maintaining a monetary anchor recalls past efforts to balance stability, elasticity, and political authority. While a digital euro is a necessary component for sustaining the anchor in an increasingly digital financial system, it alone cannot guarantee monetary unity. Effective anchoring presupposes robust political integration, a clear separation between monetary and fiscal objectives, and a private financial sector that can provide elastic credit.
Area:
Keywords: Digital Euro, Monetary Anchor, Gresham`s law, Currency School
Please Login in order to download this file