Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Production of economic knowledge during the authoritarian regime in Portugal (1926-1974)

Cardoso José Luís, ICS - Universidade de Lisboa

PLEASE NOE THIS SUBMISSION IS INCLUDED IN THE SESSION ORGANIZED BY THE IBERIAN ASSOCIATION ON HET, TITLED "The political limits to economics: Iberian perspectives" This contribution seeks to describe the successive stages in the training of economists at the service of the authoritarian regime of the Estado Novo (New State) that ruled over Portugal between 1926 and 1974. Its main aim is to show the changes that occurred in the understanding of the problems related with the development of the Portuguese economy, seeking to elucidate the processes of legitimation of an authoritarian regime, but also to show the signs of a critical break with a model of economic and social organisation and a political regime that had reached the point of exhaustion. Indeed, many economists of this period served the regime as ideologues and mentors, while a significant number of professional economists successfully managed to create an alternative to the conventional neoclassical theory and doctrine. Corporatist economists faithful to Salazar’s rule, with a background education in law schools, produced a rationale that attributed a major economic role to government. However, a similar demand for state economic intervention was also put forward by engineers and economists, motivated by the pragmatic purposes of catching up with and emulating the developed economies and inspired by other streams of economic thought, including Keynesian macroeconomics. Though informed by different ideological and philosophical presuppositions, these streams of thought shared the same strong criticism of the neoclassical notion of a market equilibrium achieved through the actions of a purely spontaneous mechanism. Therefore, the notion of market failure and the need to ensure a feasible social and economic order were at the very heart of the arguments developed by a second wave of both neo-corporatists and Keynesians, seeking to justify the economic role of government. The tacit acceptance of Keynesian arguments by the political leaders of Salazar’s regime paved the way for the emergence of authorised voices of dissent. It is precisely this convergence that helps to explain the relevance of economists as a group of acknowledged experts and special agents with a key role in the postwar discussion of issues relating to social policy, economic development and the possibilities of (and constraints upon) the building of the welfare state under an authoritarian regime.

Area:

Keywords: Iberian economic thought, Portugal, authoritarianism, corporatism, economic policy

Please Login in order to download this file