Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Some Insights on the Political Limits of Economics under the Francoist Dictatorship: Contributions of Zumalacárregui and Andrés Álvarez

Trincado Aznar Estrella, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
Gallego Abaroa Elena, Complutense University of Madrid

The Spanish economists José María Zumalacárregui and Valentín Andrés Álvarez were acutely aware of the political limits to change. Álvarez, not only economist but also a playwriter, criticized society through literature, embedding a subtle cynicism within the Theatre of the Absurd, aligning with what has been called “the other Generation of ’27,” which was guided by humorism. One of his plays, Tararí, depicts asylum inmates who rebel and imprison their caretakers. When the police arrive, they cannot distinguish the sane from the insane, thereby questioning conventional notions of justice and injustice, madness and reason. In his studies on Spain’s foreign trade statistics, Álvarez addressed the issue of data reliability in economic research, emphasizing the political dimension underlying the economy. Data on foreign trade prior to 1930 were flawed not only due to technical issues but also because of political pressures. Trade figures were frequently manipulated for political purposes: liberals promoted an artificial reduction of the deficit, whereas conservatives did the opposite to justify protectionism and use the figures as leverage in foreign trade negotiations. This manipulation underscored the pervasive intersection of economic analysis, political influence, and the performative “insanity” of policy decision-making. In 1930, Zumalacárregui was appointed Rector of the University of Valencia by Royal Decree; however, believing that the appointment had originated from political rather than academic authority, he offered his position to the faculty. He was after dismissed by the Republican government in 1931. Both economists were profoundly affected by the outbreak of the Spanish Civil War (1936–1939). After the war, they secured chairs at the Complutense University of Madrid. From academia, they sought to promote economic knowledge and taught economics grounded in marginalism, incorporating the latest European advances. They contributed to the modernization of the Spanish economy and advocated for social policies, including the expansion of social insurance and a fairer tax system, while highlighting the persistent problem of tax fraud. However, the constraints of politics were always present in their lives, but they found a somewhat comfortable refuge within academia, under a dictatorship.

Area:

Keywords: political manipulation of data, economics under dictatorship, institutional framework, Spanish economists

Please Login in order to download this file