Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

The Falsification of Mercantilism: The Tragic Deviation of Economic Theory

Fudulu Paul, University of Bucharest

There is no explicit idea and no other basis to conclude that the great mercantilist writers - Serra, Mun, Steuart - thought or suggested that they confused metallic money with wealth. Additionally, important mercantilist ideas are clearly inconsistent with such confusion. The classical liberal economists Adam Smith and John. S. Mill grossly misunderstood mercantilist tenets and, I regret to say, intentionally falsified it. The misunderstanding stemmed from their different perspective. A good example in that regard is the difference in understanding the notion of wealth. While mercantilists were focused mainly on relative wealth, which was adequate for the epoch they lived in, the classical economists had in their minds only the concept of absolute wealth. The falsification was done in two ways. First, irrelevant facts were brought in when the mercantilist ideas were assessed, such as when Adam Smith talked about the availability of other means of payment for the expenses of wars in distant countries besides gold and silver. A great deal of this falsification was produced by avoiding a rigorous analysis of the mercantilists’ main books, and relying on inventions and economic folklore. Mill never quotes any mercantilist thinker while Smith gives a few quotations from Mun regarding ideas that are not representative of the mercantilist system. A shocking example is Smith’s complete avoidance of Steuart’s great book An Inquiry into the Principles of Political Oeconomy, although Smith was his contemporary and that book is the least one to be ignored even regarding non-mercantilist issues. In addition to all I have said above, Smith and Mill made a gross methodological error in analyzing mercantilism: They employed principles belonging to a particular economic system―the classical liberal one―to assess a different economic system pertaining to another national culture and another historical period. As a general relevant conclusion I put forth this: The classical liberal economic thinking represented here by Smith and Mill and its critique of mercantilism stifled economic thinking which at that time was on a sound path. Smith and Mill forced a tragic turn: from a potentially sound meta-theory based on Steuart’s enormous contribution to a narrow theory centered on Western national culture in only one of its historical periods. Claiming universality or the status of representing an ideal economic system later entailed numerous internal and external inconsistencies and a low causally explanatory capacity.

Area:

Keywords: economic systems, mercantilism, economic methodology

Please Login in order to download this file