Karl William Kapp’s self-censorship in The Social Costs? The Hidden Strand from the Socialist Calculation Debate to Ecological Economics
Karl William Kapp is mostly known as a critic of the damages which a capitalist economy entails (through his 1950 book The Social Costs of Private Entreprise), but also, increasingly so, as one of the founders of Ecological Economics (if not as an institutional actor, at least as a an intellectual one) and of the very idea of ecological planning. However, it is striking to note that even though The Social Costs is a continuation of a strand of his 1936 PhD thesis, not only is it the most moderate one, drawing from Pigou, but also, it is not the main strand by which Kapp will contribute to founding theoretically Ecological Economics. His contribution on the matter lies in a complex second strand, which starts from his PhD Thesis and goes through small general texts on planning, development economics in India, texts on new indicators after the emergence of new ecological stakes in the 1970s and finally the study of environmental planning in China. My hypothesis, connected to the theme of the conference, is that, as an exiled German intellectual in the US in the 1950s, Kapp could not strongly advocate for planning within the political American context (as the various drafts of the introduction of The Social Costs show), hence the fact that he opted for a rather mild critique instead of focusing on finding conceptual tools to analyze every type of economy, including socialist planned economies, in order to promote socialist planned economies, i.e. the objective of the second strand. This hypothesis might also explain why Kapp gradually moved away from the first edition of The Social costs (1950) up to the point of acknowledging that the first edition resorted to a Marshallian concept of social cost as an externality.
Area:
Keywords: Karl William Kapp ; Self-Censorship ; Social Costs ; Socialist Calculation Debate ; Ecological Planning
Please Login in order to download this file