Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Alfred Marshall’s ‘Wellbeing’ and Pigou’s ‘Economic Welfare’ in the History of Welfare Economics and the Welfare State

Nishizawa Tamotsu, Emeritus Professor, Hitotsubashi University

‘Wellbeing’ now seems to be in fashion. In the time of welfare economics in the making, Alfred Marshall wrote that ‘Wealth exists only for the benefit of mankind. ….its true measure lies only in the contribution it makes to human well-being.’ Marshall was much more concerned with ‘well-being’ rather than ‘welfare’, or he was more concerned with welfare in general, or ‘general wellbeing’, ‘social wellbeing’ or ‘human wellbeing’, in contrast with Pigou’s ‘economic welfare’, separated from welfare in general. In the Principles of Economics, Marshall uses ‘wellbeing’ far more often than ‘welfare’, whereas Pigou limited ‘welfare’ to ‘economic welfare’ by means of the ‘measuring rod of money’ in the Economics of Welfare, which starts with the chapter ‘welfare and economic welfare’. I would like to investigate here, 1)how Marshall uses ‘wellbeing’ in the Principles in particular; or the meaning and significance of ‘wellbeing’ in the Principles and in his economic thought; then to make clearer the contrast (and difference) with Pigou’s ‘economic welfare’ in Economics of Welfare, 2) to compare Marshall’s ‘wellbeing’ and Pigou’s ‘economic welfare’ in the history of welfare economics, to discuss about Marshall’s welfare economic thinking and Pigou’s welfare economics, suggesting that some elements of ‘wellbeing’ having lost in the making of scientific welfare economics or making welfare economics into science; then further to consider some commonality and continuity between Marshall and Pigou in their welfare state thinking of the Cambridge School, referring to and comparing with the Oxford Economists, lastly 3) to consider its implication and to make a suggestion to the current arguments of GDP and beyond GDP approach. Marshall vs Pigou, Marshall’s wellbeing vs Pigou’s economic welfare, Marshall’s economic thought on wellbeing (quality of life) and sustainability might give some suggestions, to the current problem of GDP and beyond GDP approach such as the Better Life Index.

Area:

Keywords: Alfred Marshall, A.C. Pigou, wellbeing, economic welfare, history of welfare economics

Please Login in order to download this file