Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

[YSP] The voice of God and Nature versus the Wrath of God: Las Casas, Azpilcueta, and New World Inflation

Batt David, University of Notre Dame Du Lac

This paper explores the relationship between political power and the production of economic knowledge in mid-sixteenth-century Spain, examining how the political project of the conquest of the Americas generated varying intellectual responses. As has been understood for some time now, the massive influx of precious metals from the New World coincided with a period of severe inflation and widespread social disorder in sixteenth-century Spain, demanding explanations from jurists and theologians. In this paper I will examine the different ways Bartolomé de Las Casas and Martín de Azpilcueta responded to high prices and the influx of precious metals in the context of criticizing the Spanish conquest of the Americas on the one hand and accommodating the practices of merchants and commercial trade on the other. The Dominican friar Bartolomé de Las Casas was highly critical of the treatment of indigenous peoples in the Americas. He utilized the Thomist natural law tradition to critique the practice of encominenda and interpreted the economic crisis that resulted from the influx of precious metals from the Americas — characterized, he noted, by a tripling of prices — as an explicit act of divine punishment and a manifestation of special divine providence outside the natural order. In this sense, I argue, Las Casas’s use of prophetic rhetoric served as a strategy of resistance, highlighting the transgressions against natural law committed by the Spanish crown and conquistadores. In contrast, Martín de Azpilcueta, while broadly supporting Las Casas’s moral positions against the system of encomienda, sought to characterize the transportation of precious metals from the Americas and the resulting rise in prices as a natural, rather than supernatural, phenomenon. This was based on the work of jurists and theologians from the School of Salamanca, and grounded rising prices in God’s general providential action, what Azpilcueta characterized as the “the voice of God and nature”: as the quantity of gold and silver increases, its value decreases making everything else dearer. For Azpilcueta, I will argue, the fact that money could change its value due to abundance and scarcity caused a high degree of uncertainty when it came to mercantile exchange. This uncertainty meant that merchants could not necessarily be held morally culpable of violating Aristotelian commutative justice if they profited when trading licitly. Thus, while Las Casas used economic phenomena for political resistance, Azpilcueta developed a tool that provided a framework for legitimating certain economic actions “in good conscience” amidst the uncertainties and atrocities caused by Spanish imperial policy.

Area:

Keywords: Sixteenth-century Spain; Martín de Azpilcueta; Bartholomé de Las Casas; American Gold and Silver; Quantity Theory of Money; Salamanca

Please Login in order to download this file