Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Contrasting interpretations of Cantillon's Essai: implications for the entrepreneur

Curran Declan, Dublin City University

The emergence in recent decades of Entrepreneurship as a research domain in its own right presents an interesting question for scholars of Richard Cantillon’s Essai sur la Nature du Commerce en Général: does Cantillon’s entrepreneur – ubiquitous across the Essai – now enjoy a relevance that extends beyond the field of Economics? Unfortunately, however, a full appraisal of Cantillon’s entrepreneur has been impeded by contrasting interpretations of the Essai. Early commentary, from Jevons’ rediscovery of Cantillon’s work in 1881 to Hayek’s 1931 introduction to the German translation, characterized the Essai as a treatise and discussed selected aspects of the Essai rather than the Essai’s overarching schema. However, Schumpeter’s History of Economic Analysis (1954) characterizes Cantillon as a system builder (of a Walrasian type) and thereby placed the emphasis firmly on the methodological and epistemological underpinnings of the Essai. What has emerged since are two very different readings of Cantillon, each of which marshals features of the Essai to support a distinct methodological and epistemological position. One on hand, Neo-Ricardian scholars point to Cantillon’s work as demonstrating a surplus theory of value, replete with an objective intrinsic value concept and a determinate equilibrium. Subjective scholars of the Austrian tradition, on the other hand, see in the Essai a depiction of a dynamic market process, in with monetary changes impact unevenly on the pricing structure and have uncertain consequences for real economic activity. And what of the entrepreneur? While recent scholarship appears to have reaffirmed the determinate thread à la William Petty that runs through Cantillon’s Essai, an equilibrium reading inevitably circumscribes the nature and role of Cantillon’s entrepreneur within the Essai. The entrepreneur’s economic function - central as it is to Cantillon’s model - reduces to producer/supplier and is arguably not an entrepreneurial endeavour in any modern sense. Whereas a subjective reading of the Essai that emphasizes uncertainty and market adjustment is more amenable to a nuanced entrepreneur conception – but at the risk of denying core features of the Essai that are incongruent with such a reading. To compound matters, the Entrepreneurship research domain that has emerged since the early 2000s has gravitated towards a dynamic characterization of economic activity that eschews determinate equilibrium modelling and sees entrepreneurship as a nexus of individual and process. This paper seeks to extricate Cantillon’s entrepreneur from what has become a dichotomous methodological debate. It is argued here that placing Cantillon within the methodological tradition of Petty and Locke does not require one to downplay aspects of the Essai that run counter to that methodological line. Indeed, both Petty and Locke – like Cantillon – display consummate ease in acknowledging phenomena beyond the quantitative while retaining their empirical bent. But more importantly in light of contrasting recent interpretations of Cantillon’s Essai, it is argued in this paper that the subjective elements of the Essai are most likely the remnants of a British ‘discourses of trade’ literature rather than the legacy of a scholastic tradition. Untangling these strands in Cantillon’s Essai is a prerequisite to providing a full assessment of Cantillon’s entrepreneur. Taken as a whole, recognizing Cantillon’s entrepreneur as a function within a determinate economic system should not mean that we discard the insights that Cantillon provides regarding the entrepreneur as sentient person and entrepreneurship as a wider socio-economic phenomenon.

Area:

Keywords: Cantillon entrepreneur methodology Petty Locke

Please Login in order to download this file