Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Opinion-makers”, social norms and Kuhnian paradigm shift

russell Ellen, Wilfrid Laurier University

Kuhnian “normal science“ suggests an evolving path dependency that codifies disciplinary standards. (such as peer review that favours conformity with established disciplinary standards). This paper investigates how intra-disciplinary conformity interacts with emerging social norms concerning the legitimacy and relevance of economic analysis. Specialized economic analysis is inaccessible to the public, thus public perceptions of economic ideas and policies are shaped via discussion in journalistic and other venues. Nonspecialists disadvantaged in scrutinizing technical economics frequently rely on indications of “epistemic authority” to- ascertain the merits of an economic analysis. Thus prestigious economists [Nobel prizes, excellent publication records, influential institutional locations etc.] have great influence on public perceptions of economic possibility and necessity. Nonspecialists are also likely to view visually apparent aspects of economic analysis (mathematics, graphs etc.) as connoting expertise in that it represents conformity to prevailing standards of disciplinary excellence. In this way, social norms play a role in influencing how economic analysis is conducted and presented if they are to be persuasive to noneconomists. This suggests that intra-disciplinary path dependencies interact with social norms that litigate what economics can and should do. To respond to prevailing perceptions, economists seeking to expand their influence assess the evolving context in which decision-makers and the public adjudicate the merits of economics analysis. This suggests the possibility that economic analysis can be subtly or overtly impacted as influential politicians or elites reshape social norms about economic necessity and desirability. A politician wishing to impose a tax, tariff or other economic policy many successfully encourage social norms that validate evaluatory criteria that are sympathetic to this policy. For example, perhaps such an “opinion maker” successfully portrays economic inequality as an unreasonable consideration for economic analyses. In this event, economists are incentivized to generate analyses that respond to this emerging view. Even if economists merely refrain from generating dissenting analyses, the lack of countervailing evidence and analysis will help to encourage momentum for this “paradigm shift”.

Area:

Keywords: Kuhn, discourse, social norms, paradigm shift

Please Login in order to download this file