Technique vs imagination: a lost insight in economics
Economics has increasingly become a "technique" based on a set of analytical tools and expressed through mathematical modelling. This technical approach to economics has its roots in the marginalist revolution and the early stages of neoclassical economics. Alfred Marshall is one of those economists who contributed most to shaping that economic technique: his analytical toolbox has become an indispensable apparatus for generations of economists who have subsequently refined and enriched it. It is interesting, however, to go back to Marshall: not only because Marshall himself, in providing that toolbox, limited its scope of application. This story is rather well known (see Arena and Caldari 2024; Caldari 2015 and 2018). But because even if he was providing the analytical tools that would largely contribute to the formation of economists' analytical technique, Marshall emphasized the importance and need for economists to use not those tools but imagination. This suggestion was neglected by most, who preferred to focus on the application (and/or further development) of the technique. The reasons are well explained by Shackle in his Epistemics and Economics. As Shackle notes, even if "Imagination and Reason are the two faculties that make us human….the economic analyst has opted for Reason” (1972; Preface) leaving aside as much as possible imagination. Imagination was seen as an obstacle or a foreign body in the world of logic, of the "given and delimited premises" (1972: 444). Indeed, when taken into account, imagination has been considered mainly for its role in stimulating creativity and innovation (Schumpeter) or as the source of the economists’ metaphorical language (McCloskey; Mirowski). Yet, the role that Marshall recognizes for imagination is different, and much more far-reaching. In his Principles of Economics, he stresses: “The economist needs the three great intellectual faculties, perception, imagination and reason: and most of all he needs imagination” (1920: 43). There are several reasons that explain that need but the most important is for Marshall that with and through imagination the economist “may develop his ideals” (1920: 46). In this paper I dwell upon the crucial function of imagination according to Marshall and on the consequences that the loss of track of his insight has had, in my view, especially in terms of suggestions and choices of economic policy. References Arena R. and Caldari K. (2024) “Léon Walras and Alfred Marshall: Microeconomic rational choice or human and social nature?", Cambridge Journal of Economics, 48(3): 369-396. Caldari K. (2018), “Alfred Marshall and François Perroux: the neglected liaison”, European Journal of the History of Economic Thought: 25(2 April): 134-174. Caldari K. (2015), “Marshall and Complexity: a necessary balance between process and order”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 39(4): 1071-1085. Marshall A. (1920), Principles of Economics, London: Macmillan Shackle G.L.S. (1972), Epistemics and Economics. A critique of economic doctrine, Cambridge: CUP.
Area:
Keywords: imagination; solidarity; progress; state
Please Login in order to download this file