Reaction of Czechoslovak Economists to Totalitarian Pressure
For about a hundred years before communism, during the Habsburg Monarchy, and in the interwar period, the Czech and Slovak lands, for the most part, have enjoyed wide-ranging freedom of public discussion about economic matters. These freedoms were suppressed after 1948 and replaced by pressure to align independent opinions with the government's views. There were three fundamental restrictions. First, there was a restriction on economic theory as such, as the mainstream Western theory was compulsorily replaced by the Marxist economic theory, in its Soviet version. Books of non-Marxist, liberal, and typical mainstream macroeconomics and microeconomics were prohibited, or at least were not used in universities and schools. In this paper, we will not address the first restriction, i.e., we will not discuss the separation but also the partial overlap between the mainstream Western theory and the Marxist theory. Second, in the early 1950s, there was persecution of mild (non-Stalinist) Marxist economists as well as persecution of the leading representatives of economic thought during the interwar period. We will present cases from Czechoslovak economic history concerning the persecution in the early 1950s of leading economists, including Karel Engliš (1880-1961), Imrich Karvaš (1903-1981), Eugen Loebl (1907-1987), Ludwig Frejka (1904-1952), and others. Third, there was a restriction on the process of opinion-making and on the freedom to publish if the message ran counter to official explanations. We present the case of Ota Šik (1919-2004), who, during the reform process of the 1960s, was able to express his critical, partially anti-Marxist views through the art of writing between the lines. The communist oppression meant that the society was not given the opportunity to choose between two or more views, especially not between the Marxist and non-Marxist opinions, as no public writers who could step in and discuss with the authorities. However, different views were presented within the government (the Communist Party). Such discussion was constrained by the requirement that views be expressed in Marxist jargon, and the authors were to avoid mainstream economic language. Such authors expressed their opinions cautiously or wrote between the lines. An economist living in a totalitarian country might doubt the quality or efficiency of the state's economic policy. The author could publish a paper or a book presenting his critical views. However, he needs to hide these views from the ordinary reader. In other words, the book needs to devote ample space to attacks on the bourgeois view, with plenty of citations from the Marxist classics. He could insert arguments criticizing the state into the text, which only cautious readers (similarly reform-minded economists) will notice, as they learn to read between the lines. An ordinary reader (in our study, representatives of the state and political power) of such a paper would not see anything critical in it, as the paper on the first site follows the typical style of other apologetic papers. Most of the party members, including the Communist Party elite were from the point of view of the Marxist theory thoughtless readers (they never read Marx in German, neither in Czech, or Slovak, they grew up on brochures issued by Institutes of Marxist-Leninism, which were intellectually simplified, apologetic documents artificially connecting some sections of the Marxist doctrine with the current Communist Party policies).
Area:
Keywords: Czechoslovak economic thought, communist economies
Please Login in order to download this file