Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Attracting Starlings: Locust Invasions, Taxation, and the Role of Starling Sheikhs in Ottoman Society

Yeşilyurt Şahin, Ankara Yıldırım Beyazıt University

This study examines the historically significant practice of “starling water” within the Ottoman Empire, situating it within broader questions about how political power, institutional constraints, and religious authority shaped the production and circulation of economic knowledge. In an agrarian society periodically devastated by locust invasions, the Ottoman administration relied on a variety of tools—both practical and symbolic—to mitigate economic loss. One such tool was the use of starlings, natural predators of locusts. Yet the key question was how to mobilize these birds effectively. From the early periods of Ottoman rule, a special kind of sacred water, believed to attract starlings, was employed for this purpose. The procurement of this water depended on a particular group of Sufi sheikhs, especially the Semerkandî family of the Ankara region, whose activities were extensively recorded in the imperial archives. The role of these “starling sheikhs” illustrates how political and fiscal institutions could shape economic practices under conditions of constraint. The Semerkandî sheikhs were granted tax exemptions in return for their service, demonstrating a form of fiscally embedded obligation rather than a mere privilege. Similar arrangements recur throughout Ottoman taxation history, where exemptions served as instruments to secure specific administrative or economic tasks. Nevertheless, the sheikhs’ position was not free from tension: local tax officials occasionally challenged their exemptions, confiscated property, or imposed levies, reflecting competing institutional interests and the fragility of negotiated autonomy under imperial rule. The mobility of the starling sheikhs—who travelled widely across the empire, particularly in the Balkans—further underscores the interplay between political authority, religious status, and economic function. Their duties granted them social recognition, while state-sanctioned privileges reinforced their legitimacy. Yet these same privileges invited imitation and abuse, prompting the Ottoman administration to investigate fraudulent claims to the title of starling sheikh. Such inquiries reveal how the state sought to regulate the boundaries of religious authority and maintain control over practices tied to economic well-being. Finally, the case raises epistemic questions concerning the nature of starling water itself. Contemporary debates interrogate whether this water should be seen as a form of “magical” substance or as part of a broader repertoire of early modern environmental knowledge. By analysing starling water and the institutional status of its practitioners, this study contributes to a deeper understanding of how political, religious, and fiscal constraints shaped the production and dissemination of economic knowledge in the Ottoman Empire.

Area:

Keywords: Taxation, Talisman, Ottoman Empire

Please Login in order to download this file