Tullock, Downs, and the Beginning of the Virginia School of Political Economy
Gordon Tullock’s engagement with Anthony Downs over the limitations of majority voting proved an important impetus to the establishment of the Virginia Political Economy research program and the writing of Calculus of Consent (1962). Although much work has been done on the origins of Virginia Political Economy and Calculus, the precise circumstances and motivations underlying the Tullock and Downs 1958 – 1960 exchanges remain obscure. In this paper, we reconstruct how the rapid evolution in Tullock’s thinking was sparked by his engagement with Downs through a series of papers, replies, rejoinders, and letters. We demonstrate how their works are inextricably linked, and how the intellectual stimulation and substantive disagreements between Downs and Tullock precipitated important advances. From his initial exploration into the limits of majority voting, Tullock was pushed to consider a range of potential solutions that included logrolling and other compensation schemes. Finding these insufficient, Tullock turned his attention to the rules of the game and the meta-conditions under which collective decisions are made.
Area:
Keywords: Anthony Downs, Gordon Tullock, collective decision-making, voting rules, public choice
Please Login in order to download this file