The Temporality of Interest Rates in Knut Wicksell’s Thought
Unlike the monetary analyses of the first half of the 19th century, which focus on short-term indebtedness (see Henry Thornton, 1802; Thomas Tooke, 1840; John Stuart Mill, 1844), late-century economists such as Knut Wicksell, Irving Fisher, William S. Jevons, and Robert Giffen turned their attention to long-term debt. This interest in the long term can be explained by the development of industry, which required more long-term financing, as well as by the influence of Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk, according to whom long-term investments create wealth and employment (1884). However, he did not address the issue of indebtedness, something Wicksell sought to remedy by attempting to apply Böhm-Bawerk’s theory of the temporal structure of capital to the market for long-term debt. In Wicksell’s theory, interest rates of different maturities trigger a well-known cumulative process, namely a continuous rise in the price level. With this dynamic approach, in which equilibrium is unstable, Wicksell sets himself apart from the static analysis of Léon Walras. However, little research has examined Wicksell’s long-term monetary rate, which, together with the short-term rate, constitutes the monetary rate. The most recent book by Bruna Ingrao and Claudio Sardoni further undermines this contribution by Wicksell (Bruna and Ingrao, 2019, p. 65). According to them, Wicksell’s writings offer too little material to study the relationship between monetary interest rates of different maturities. This claim is surprising, since John Maynard Keynes emphasised this major contribution by Wicksell in A Treatise on Money (1930, vol. I, chap. 13, p. 197), arguing that it is precisely the long-term monetary rate that influences the level of fixed-capital investment, thereby stimulating growth and creating employment. Considering the points outlined above—on one side, a literature that touches only superficially on the temporality of interest rates in Wicksell, and on the other, Keynes’s insistence on the importance of this contribution—it seems important to deepen research on the temporality of interest rates in Wicksell. After examining the determination of the short-term monetary rate in Wicksell’s theory (Part 1), we analyse the formation of the long-term monetary interest rate (Part 2). Lastly, Part 3 focuses on the cumulative process by linking the monetary rate (short and long) with the natural rate (which is also a long-term rate). In conclusion, the author agrees with Keynes, who highlighted several ambiguities in Wicksell’s theory of interest rates. These difficulties would later give rise to the (rather) well-known controversy between Sraffa, Hayek, and Keynes in the 1930s, although this lies beyond the scope of the present inquiry.
Area:
Keywords: Banks, Capital, Expectations, Cumulative process, Interest rates (short and long), Temporality
Please Login in order to download this file