The Austrian School under pressure: its history and philosophy
Members of a school that long confronted authoritarian regimes, from its birth to our times, the leaders and followers of Austrian School of Economics opposed many nationalistic governments throughout the 20th century. This paper aims at putting the spotlight on a few issues, from its start to present. The Austro-Hungarian empire where Carl Menger was born was not only a “jail for nationalities”, but also a place to thrive for many theories that enhanced their chances of heading towards modernization. What were the founder’s reactions to the frame within which he had to dwell and fight a much more authoritative tendency within German-speaking Academia, namely the Kathedersozialisten of the German Historical School ? The disciples of the first generation fought against socialism of all parties (as Friedrich Hayek put it in the opening address of his Road to Serfdom) and that included forms of control over the economy within the nationalistic dictatorships that brought turmoil to Europe and the world. How would the same, albeit at the end of his career, be regarded as possibly supporting the Chilian regime? Another paradox regards some trends illustrated by Friedrich von Wieser in his 1926 das Gesetz der Macht to admire leadership not only in economic entrepreneurship, but in the form of Italian fascism or Portuguese corporatist state? Isn’t there a paradox when almost all liberal Austrians (Jewish or not) fled the regimes that rendered life intolerable in Vienna? The basic Austrian economic assumptions are to be examined where paradoxes emerge within history. This paper intends to do exactly that. In contemporary times, much has been debated about qualifications terms such as used by journalists like “neoliberalism” or “ultraliberalism”, both explicitly rebuked by Hayek. There are within the Austrian doctrine basic tenants making authoritarianism their main adversary, and yet it has sometimes been reproached that its doctrine could support coercive views of the world: this has to do with a stage of development of this school that emerged when major names such as Hayek, Schumpeter - with a debate, Ludwig von Mises - without discussion, as well as Menger’s son, Karl, or Gottfried Haberler and so many others, emigrated to America. Besides Karen Vaughn’s introductory book on the matter, this paper wishes to explore more of the connection that led a Misesian like Murray Rothbard to debate strategy allying with Conservative movements specific to the US context. Political philosophy meets economic philosophy there, and although this paper will stop short of dealing with current politics, it shall present aspects that make history of the Austrian school significant for our days.
Area:
Keywords: Austrian School of economics, Carl Menger, Friedrich von Wieser, Friedrich Hayek, Ludwig von Mises, Murray Rothbard
Please Login in order to download this file