Transmitting Economic Ideology Under Autocratic Constraint: Institutional Channels and the Decline of Women's Economic Agency in Imperial Russia, 1780s-1840s
This paper examines how autocratic regimes shape economic behavior not through legal restrictions but through systematic transmission of constraining ideologies via institutional channels. Using the case of Russian noblewomen's economic agency (1780s-1840s), I demonstrate how political power transformed actual economic practice despite unchanged property rights, a puzzle with broader implications for understanding how authoritarian contexts limit economic knowledge and behavior. Russian noblewomen retained robust property rights throughout this period. Female wealth ownership expanded from 10% in the 1720s to 40% by the 1810s, with legal frameworks protecting separate property, inheritance rights, and independent economic action. Yet women's actual economic agency paradoxically diminished. Where the 1780s generation confidently managed estates and navigated commercial networks, the 1820s-1840s generation was relegated to "household matters" whilst men assumed economic control. Property rights persisted; economic agency vanished. The answer lies in the convergence of five mutually reinforcing institutional channels transmitting constraining economic ideology: (1) expanding state-controlled institutional education; (2) self-education through selectively imported Enlightenment texts promoting domesticity over economic autonomy; (3) educational trips abroad; (4) post-Napoleonic ideology creating masculine identities centered on martial heroism rather than economic partnership; (5) family socialization transmitting new gender norms across generations. These channels operated sporadically in earlier generations but converged decisively in the 1820s-1840s. The cohort coming of age after 1820 encountered all channels simultaneously from childhood, transforming what had been pragmatic acceptance of female economic management into active ideological resistance. Prescriptive literature became bestsellers teaching women to hide their economic agency as improper "властолюбие" (power-seeking). Men educated through these channels—including Decembrists shaped by Enlightenment readings—positioned wives as emotional dependents requiring male guidance even while recognizing lower-class women's economic competence when convenient. My methodological approach combines quantitative analysis of property ownership patterns with qualitative examination of transmission mechanisms using archival sources: family correspondence, institutional curricula, library catalogues, prescriptive literature, and memoirs. This demonstrates how autocratic institutional structures constrain economic behavior through ideological control—a model applicable to other contexts where formal institutions (property law) diverge from actual practice due to systematic transmission of constraining economic ideologies. The paper contributes to understanding how political constraints shape economic thought and behavior in authoritarian contexts, showing that state control operates not only through censorship and coercion but through coordinated institutional channels that make certain economic choices "unthinkable" even when legally permitted.
Area:
Keywords: Russian Empire, Gender, Enlightenment, Economic Thought
Please Login in order to download this file