From Moral Ties to Market Rules: The Changing Idea of Reciprocity
This paper examines how the concept of reciprocity was transformed in classical and early neoclassical economics, moving from a plural and morally embedded set of social relations to a more narrowly defined and analytically closed framework centred on market exchange. Drawing on Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill, and Alfred Marshall, I argue that this transformation cannot be explained solely by changes in nineteenth-century economic life. Rather, it reflects a process of theoretical selection shaped by what I call narrative closure: the preference for explanatory frameworks that are determinate, commensurable, and self-terminating. In Smith, reciprocity operates through multiple, non-equivalent registers, including exchange, justice, beneficence, sympathy, and role-based obligation. Some of these relations lend themselves to analytical closure, while others remain open-ended and resistant to formalization. Mill preserves this plurality but reorganizes it by distinguishing between the law-like domain of production and exchange and the institutionally contingent domain of distribution and social reform. Marshall extends this process further by developing analytic techniques, especially equilibrium reasoning and marginal analysis, that render a wider range of social relations tractable within a closed economic framework. Distribution itself becomes incorporated into the analytic core of economics through marginal productivity theory. The paper argues that narrative closure functions as a selection principle in the development of economics, shaping not only which forms of reciprocity become central to economic explanation but also the boundaries of the discipline itself.
Area:
Keywords: narrative; Adam Smith; reciprocity; historiography, JS Mill, Alfred Marshall
Please Login in order to download this file