Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Can Socialism Work? Of Course it Can’t! Schumpeter on Capitalism, Socialism and Economic Change

Guichardaz Rémy, University of Strasbourg BETA
Pénin Julien, University of Strasbourg BETA

In Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, Schumpeter famously predicted that capitalism would eventually give way to socialism, and that such a socialist order could, in principle, prove both viable and efficient. This claim has often been taken too literally, and consequently interpreted as paradoxical, given Schumpeter’s lifelong effort to theorize capitalism as a process of creative destruction. This article revisits that tension by mobilizing core concepts of Schumpeterian dynamics, particularly his ontology of the entrepreneur and his conception of novelty. We show that, for Schumpeter, genuine economic development depends on the irreducibly creative agency of entrepreneurs, whose imaginative and extra-rational capacities cannot be replicated by bureaucratic or collectivist structures. The, against the Mises-Hayek critique, which locates the limits of socialism in the epistemic impossibility of rational economic calculation, Schumpeter’s argument is fundamentally sociological: socialism destroys the institutional and psychological foundations that make entrepreneurship, and thus development, possible. In highlighting this distinction, we argue that Schumpeter’s apparent concession to socialism conceals a deeper philosophical conviction: that novelty - much like artistic creation - lies beyond the reach of rationalized or deterministic systems, and depends instead on exceptional individuals sustained by a complex social and institutional nexus inherited from both medieval and capitalist civilizations.

Area:

Keywords: Schumpeter, entrepreneur, capitalism, socialism, development, growth

Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.