Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Economists and Their Political and Moral Limits

Blanco Alfredo Felix, Universidad Nacional de Córdoba. Argentina.
Luc Melisa Janet, Universidad Nacional de Cordoba
Godino Franco, Universidad Nacional de Cordoba

Modern economics strives assiduously to present itself as a discipline whose scientific objectivity is beyond question. However, the neutrality regarding ends that it frequently claims is increasingly subject to doubt. Economists are often constrained by their own ideological and political perspectives, which impose limits on the ostensibly "objective" application of economic reasoning. Furthermore, extra-intellectual factors shape both their theoretical constructs and practical applications. This paper examines the political constraints inherent in Economics, the mechanisms that produce them, and their evolution throughout the history of economic thought. The politicization of economic institutions—many of them multilateral, such as the IMF and the World Bank—along with the imperative to address social problems through public policy design, among other factors, increasingly reveals these "limits of economics." These are not merely technical or methodological constraints but are profoundly political in nature. The gap, and often the direct contradiction, between the antiseptic nature of Pareto-efficient equilibrium posited by welfare economics and the reality of a conflict-ridden society presents a nearly insurmountable barrier to maintaining the discipline's claimed "objectivity." This paper argues that it would be highly beneficial for theoretical, academic, and professional economists to more explicitly articulate the "pre-conceptions" and normative values that underpin their economic policy recommendations. In other words, intellectual honesty demands the recognition that economists are political actors, not merely technical advisors, technocrats, or "ivory tower" scientists. The paper is structured as follows: I. From Classical Economics to the Present a) Economists as Moral Philosophers b) The Neutral Science of Utility Theorists c) Keynesianism, the Neoclassical Synthesis, and Economic Policy d) Counter-revolution and the Revival of a "Liberal" Order e) The Current Reality f) Does Economics Have a Future as a Scientific Discipline? II. Sources of Pressure on Economists a) The Politicization of Institutions b) Empirical Testing in the "Post-Truth" Era c) Social Demand for Normative Answers to Policy Questions in a Conflict-Ridden World III. Politics and Economic Rationality . IV. Conclusion: Toward a More Committed and Transparent Economics.

Area:

Keywords: Economic Objectivity, Ideology and Economics, Ethics and Economics. JEL Codes: B20, B41.

Please Login in order to download this file