Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

On the Role of Florence in the Rise of Modern Capitalism

Ardalan Kavous, Marist University

The aim of this essay is to look more closely at the role of Florence in the rise of modern capitalism through a multi-paradigmatic approach. Florence has a privileged place in discussions as a locus of modernity and capitalistic practice with regard to not only trade and merchant activity (commercial capitalism) but also accounting technique (double-entry bookkeeping), business organization, and public finance (funded debt, or monte) – the latter associated with financial capitalism. Some scholars have declared that modern capitalism has its roots in Florence, and also that the enduring romance of the city is that of emergent capitalism. The connection between Florentine capitalism and the church is conspicuous because of the city’s role in papal banking, which was a focal point of economic activity, most notably with regard to the Medici family, which itself has stood at the center of discussion. Any adequate analysis of the role of Florence in the rise of capitalism necessarily requires fundamental understanding of the worldviews underlying the views expressed with respect to the role of Florence in the rise of capitalism. This essay starts with the premise that any worldview can be associated with one of the four basic paradigms: functionalist, interpretive, radical humanist, and radical structuralist. It shows that any view expressed with respect to the role of Florence in the rise of capitalism is based on one of the four paradigms or worldviews and is equally scientific and informative. The essence of each of the four paradigms is as follows: I. The Functionalist Paradigm: It assumes that society has a concrete existence and follows a certain order. These assumptions lead to the existence of an objective and value-free social science. II. The Interpretive Paradigm: It sees the social world as a process which is created by individuals. Social reality is regarded as being a network of assumptions and intersubjectively shared meanings. III. The Radical Humanist Paradigm: It assumes that reality is socially created and sustained. It provides critiques of the status quo. It views the process of reality creation as feeding back on itself. IV. The Radical Structuralist Paradigm: It assumes that reality is objective and concrete. It is based on four central notions. First, there is the notion of totality. Second, there is the notion of structure. Third is the notion of contradiction. Fourth is the notion of crisis.

Area:

Keywords: Rise of Capitalism; Role of Florence; Multi-Paradigmatic Approach; Diversity of Viewpoints

Please Login in order to download this file